OUTPOST

OUTPOST

IDEAS

Should France abandon its colour-blind principle?

France’s republican ideal has collapsed under mass migration and failed integration

Outpost's avatar
Adam Chapman's avatar
Outpost and Adam Chapman
Oct 20, 2026
∙ Paid

The apocalyptic scenes in France at the weekend will surprise no one who has read Douglas Murray’s 2017 book The Strange Death of Europe. In his all-too-prophetic bestseller, Murray writes that Europe is ‘committing suicide’ by opening the door to uncontrolled mass migration from the Middle East, North Africa and sub-Saharan Africa. These new arrivals seek to impose their own customs, traditions, politics and religion on a continent in the grip of a crisis of confidence, faith and identity.

The Left’s reaction to Murray’s book was entirely predictable. Personal highlights include Murtaza Hussain (I had to look him up) of The Intercept (I had to look that up, too) describing his prognosis as ‘relentlessly paranoid’, and The Guardian’s equally glowing review, which ran under the headline: ‘Gentrified xenophobia’.

I suppose they would view the torching of an imposing 19th-century town hall in Limoges at the weekend as yet more evidence of relentless paranoia cooked up by conservative commentators. The desperate woman pleading with balaclava-clad rioters not to loot a supermarket was practically dripping with gentrified xenophobia.

The mainstream media would certainly have us believe that the protests were overwhelmingly peaceful. Students, trade unionists and gilets jaunes (yellow vests) mobilised to vent their legitimate frustrations over the rising cost of living. Opportunistic looters, encouraged by rabble-rousing hard-left politicians, then hijacked the protests, and anarchy ensued.

I can accept that hundreds of thousands of protesters marched peacefully on Saturday – taking to the streets is a feature, not a bug, of the Fifth Republic, after all. But that doesn’t explain what happened. To believe it does is a dangerous delusion.

I can sense the hackles rising among progressives who may have unwittingly stumbled upon my article. Blaming hard-left agitators for the riots is one thing, but attributing them directly to uncontrolled mass immigration is quite another.

But neither cramped classrooms nor the cost-of-living crisis gets to the heart of why masked men waved Palestinian flags as historic buildings went up in flames. What does a war in the Middle East have to do with the very real social and economic pressures bearing down on the French population? Even if I were willing to accept the Left’s animus towards Israel and its response to October 7, which I’m not, it still wouldn’t answer my question.

The picture starts to look clearer when we consider what the Palestinian flag has come to represent: nihilistic hatred towards the West and a jihadist assault on both Judeo-Christian values and the Enlightenment ideals sown on European soil. It is a symbol of the civilisational struggle between open and closed societies.

I’ll grant that not everyone who waves a Palestinian flag in the West is a jihadist sympathiser. But its appearance against a backdrop of anarchy raises profoundly uncomfortable questions about ideological motivations.

It makes perfect sense for young men steeped in Islamist ideology who feel no real ancestral connection to France to fly such a flag – and to do so with pride. These ‘split loyalties’, as my colleague Colin Brazier recently put it in his monologue, can manifest themselves in pernicious ways.

He notes how Frenchmen of North African origin seemed more upset, and more prone to rioting, when the countries their grandparents came from failed to win the World Cup. This example sounds trivial, but it isn’t. Tribal loyalties are often revealed in the beautiful game, in the ecstasy of victory and the violence of defeat.

Extrapolating from this example to Saturday’s riots will be a bridge too far for many on the Left and mild-mannered conservatives still clinging to the centre ground. It will strike them as conspiratorial: a convenient scapegoat with which to advance my supposed ‘far-right’ bigotry.

It doesn’t help that determining the precise demographic composition of the rioters is virtually impossible due to France’s colour-blind principle.

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2026 Outpost Studios · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture